The Mistress (2023), directed by Greg Pritikin, is a slow-burn psychological horror-thriller that blends ghostly terror with personal unraveling. Set against the backdrop of a historic home filled with secrets, the film explores the dangers of obsession, the weight of hidden guilt, and the thin line between love and possession.
The story follows newlyweds Maddie (Chasten Harmon) and Parker (John Magaro), who move into a beautiful, old house in a quiet neighborhood, hoping to start a fresh chapter. Parker, a writer struggling with self-doubt and creative block, is instantly drawn to the history of the home—especially the mysterious woman whose belongings were left behind in the attic. Among the artifacts is a trove of seductive, tragic love letters written by a woman known only as "The Mistress."
As Parker becomes obsessed with the letters, he begins to spiral. His grip on reality weakens. Strange occurrences plague the house—whispers in the dark, doors opening on their own, visions of a woman in white. Maddie, trying to hold their marriage together, suspects something far more sinister is unfolding. The house doesn't just hold memories—it holds a presence. And it's not letting go.
What unfolds is a haunting exploration of grief, betrayal, and temptation. The film is less about outright scares and more about dread and disintegration. It taps into the classic gothic tradition, where the past lingers like a ghost and emotional wounds fester in silence. The tension is psychological, built through atmosphere and character rather than jump scares.
The performances are strong, particularly Magaro as Parker, whose descent into obsession is both subtle and disturbing. Harmon brings grounded emotional weight as Maddie, whose suspicion and growing fear add urgency to the slow-burning mystery.
Visually, The Mistress leans into shadowy hallways, candlelit corners, and old-world elegance. The house becomes a character itself—beautiful but cold, a place where time seems frozen and grief echoes through the walls.
The final act brings revelations that blur the line between ghost story and psychological drama. Is Parker truly being haunted by a restless spirit, or by his own inner demons? The film leaves just enough ambiguity to linger in the mind long after the credits roll.
The Mistress is not a film of loud frights, but of quiet horror—the kind that creeps in, slowly takes hold, and reveals that sometimes, the past isn't just behind you. It's in the walls, waiting.